Skip to main content

CastleWindsor issue with MVC Area

I have been stuck with this issue and couldn't take it out of my head. Hence, ended up putting in some heavy hours solving it. But hopefully it is worth it.

THE CONTEXT:

I am implementing a MVC solution for an existing Sitecore 8.0 implementation which uses Castle Windsor for it's dependency resolver. Let's say a a tiny microsite. I had to implement a SPEAK app as per one of the requirements. Below are the 2 most important things behind why I ran into this issue in the first place:

I needed to call a WebApi from my SPEAK app.
2. I decided to take MVC Area approach for my "tiny microsite" on a completely different sets of dlls

For example the dlls for my "tiny microsite" are MyTinyApp.Web.dll, MyTinyApp.Business.dll whereas the main website's dlls are BigWebsite.Web.dll, BigWebsite.Business.dll etc. 


WHY MVC AREA:

The reason I took the MVC Area approach was to completely separate my "tiny microsite" so that I don't have to touch any of the code from "BigWebsite" implementation (Or it can also be that the code base for the "Big Website" was unavailable to me .. imagine whatever floats your boat).


THE PROBLEM:

After I implemented my MVC Area project on dll called "MyTinyApp.Web.dll" for my "tiny microsite) upon trying to call the WebApi I started getting bellow error:



From the error it's clear that the routing got resolved without any issue. But Castle Windsor for some weird reason decided to step in like "hai .. new controller .. i need to resolve this" which I would be cool with until it couldn't and threw the bizarre error that doen't make sense to begin with. 

I have never told Castle Windsor to resolve any of my stuff for "MyTinyApp.Web.dll" and the exception was getting thrown from BigWebsite.Web.dll. 

WEIRD.


THE SOLUTION:

1. Create a processor in one of your project specific config file like below:


<pipelines>
      <initialize>
                               <processor patch:before="processor[@type='Sitecore.Mvc.Pipelines.Loader.InitializeGlobalFilters, Sitecore.Mvc']" type="MyTinyApp.CastleWindsor.Pipelines.Initialize.InitializeWindsorControllerFactory, MyTinyApp.CastleWindsor" />
     </initialize>

 </pipelines>

2. Create a settings to get the assembly name associated with Big Website's dependency resolver.

  <setting name="BigWebsiteDependancyResolverAssembly" value="BigWebsite.Web.DependencyResolution.ContainerManager,BigWebsite.Web" />

3. Implement the ControllerFactory for TinyApp:


public class InitializeWindsorControllerFactory
    {
        public virtual void Process(PipelineArgs args)
        {
            string assemblyAndClass = ConfigHelper.GetValue("BigWebsiteDependancyResolverAssembly");
                Type resolverType = Type.GetType(assemblyAndClass);
                IWindsorContainer icontainer = (IWindsorContainer)(resolverType.GetProperty("Container").GetValue(null));

                icontainer.Register(Classes.FromAssemblyNamed("oblog.client.mvc").BasedOn<IController>().LifestyleTransient());
        }

    }

And waalaaa .. Double Rainbow and Unicorn,



The trick here was to get it through reflection.

Thus I do not have to touch the BigWebsite codebase at all so I can avoid deployment headache for it. Resolving though reflection makes it completely independent to any other dlls.  

"This is mainly intended for future me." but seriously CastleWindsor WTF !!!!



UPDATE:



So one of my genius colleagues figured out that original implementation of ControllerFactory in BigWebsite.Web project(csproj) had flaw in it. 

Here's his post:


So it was originally like below:

public class WindsorControllerFactory : DefaultControllerFactory
    {
        private readonly IKernel kernel;

        public WindsorControllerFactory(IKernel kernel)
        {
            this.kernel = kernel;
        }

        public override void ReleaseController(IController controller)
        {
            kernel.ReleaseComponent(controller);
        }

        protected override IController GetControllerInstance(RequestContext requestContext, Type controllerType)
        {
            if (controllerType == null)
            {
                throw new HttpException(404, string.Format("The controller for path '{0}' could not be found.", requestContext.HttpContext.Request.Path));
            }

            return (IController)kernel.Resolve(controllerType);
        }

    }

Because of this line in the implementation of the ContainerManager class which you put in the initialize pipeline:
container.Install(FromAssembly.InDirectory(new AssemblyFilter(Path.GetDirectoryName(Uri.UnescapeDataString((new UriBuilder(Assembly.GetExecutingAssembly().CodeBase)).Path)), "BigWebsite*.dll")));
the described error was getting thrown from this line :  
return (IController)kernel.Resolve(controllerType);

Weirdly, most of the blog/tutorials show this example for implementing Castle Windsor for MVC.
The fix is to have this instead:
try
            {
                return (IController)kernel.Resolve(controllerType);
            }
            catch (Exception ex)
            {
                // do something
                return base.GetControllerInstance(requestContext, controllerType);

            }

And everything else works fine from here. No need to implement extra pipeline to inject you "mvc area" implementation dll into the pipeline or modify existing implementation.


Hope it helps someone facing the same issue save time so that he/she can utilize it properly to dress up like wookie.

  



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

AIOps Agents - PoC to Prod - OpenClaw to Kagenti

AI agents are rapidly transforming software engineering—introducing new architectural patterns, terminology, and operational workflows designed to automate repetitive tasks. One of the most compelling emerging use cases is Agents for Ops . In this post, I share my journey building a Kubernetes namespace monitoring agent. Think of it as a digital intern performing Level 1 SRE tasks: it monitors K8s workloads and automatically remediates failures strictly within the guardrails of a provided knowledge base—nothing more, nothing less. I built 2 agents: 1 for K8s namespaces per cluster and 1 for VMs fleet; but to keep this post short I will focus on the k8s-namespace-monitoring-agent.   The Demo: OpenClaw: Kagenti: The usecase: My usecase is simple: The Environment: Two workloads (a web server and a database-backed microservice) running on OpenShift, with a "Chaos Monkey" injecting random failures to simulate real life application failures. The Knowledge Base: A mapping of known...

Kubectl using SSH tunnel for TKG K8s Clusters

We know SSH'ing and probably many knows about SSH tunnel. The way, in my opinion, these 2 (SSH and SSH tunnel) are different to me (and I am in favor of SSH Tunnel) is how I use it. From tooling perspective I would almost always do tunnel instead of direct ssh.  In this post I will describe how to do SSH tunnel for kubectl to interact with remote kubernetes cluster (Specifically Tanzu Kubernetes Grid aka TKG cluster). Get the project ready to go from my github:  https://github.com/alinahid477/vsphere-with-tanzu-wizard Topics Backstory SSH tunnel for TKG Clusters using Docker container Technical stuff: Tunnel through Bastion for TKG K8s cluster Technical stuff: SSH Tunnel for Kubectl for remote K8s Clusters (same with or without docker) Technical stuff: Explain me this A famous quote from Darth Vader himself: "Feel the power of SSH Tunnel" Backstory Why ssh or ssh tunnel? The below diagram shows in what scenario a SSH or SSH Tunnel almost becomes a necessity. Let's st...

Speeding using Crossplane and ServiceBinding

Software development and release processes continues to improve to deliver value to the users faster and better to support business growth and relevance in this competitive market. To achieve this we focus on automating the path to production and any people or process related obstacles of a software on its way to the user. Generally, some of the goals of the golden paths, are: Remove interdependency and promote self service and  provider & consumer relationship. Shift left - from people & process to technology & automation . Treat Platform-as-product and provide PaaS Secured and standardised by design In this post, I will describe how Crossplane and ServiceBinding can help achieve these goals in the context of applications development and delivery and their consumption of external resources / services in the process. Note:   Crossplane and  ServiceBinding both are capable of covering beyond just database connectivity. In this blog post I am describing Dat...

Understanding The Ingress and The Mesh components of Service Mesh

I wrote about the key concepts about service mesh and how to evaluate the requirements for a service mesh in my previous post here:  Deciphering the hype of Service Mesh . This post is a follow up from there covering the technical aspects. Part 1:   Deciphering the hype of Service Mesh Part 2:   Understanding The Ingress and The Mesh components of Service Mesh. Part 3: Uderstanding the observability component of Service Mesh (TBD in another post).  Almost all popular service mesh technologies/tools (eg: Istio, LinkerD) have both ingress and mesh capabilities. Conceptually, I see them as 2 mutually exclusive domain (integrated nicely by the underlying tool). Understanding  the ingress  and  the mesh  components individually, such as what they offer, what I can do with them etc, was the basic building block to my understanding of service mesh technology as a whole. This is arguably the most mis-represented topic in the internet. So, I thought,...

Jenkins on k8s - can it be this easy?

 As developers or devops we have had a somewhat love and hate relationship with Jenkins like "love oss based ci/cd that can be hosted on any environment with ranges of community plugins for pretty much anything" BUT "hate messy UI, lack of documentations, difficult to configure" etc etc. But this post isn't about pros and cons of Jenkins, rather it is about how you can get Jenkins on your k8s super quick and easy (using Merlin). Git Repo:  https://github.com/alinahid477/jenkinsonk8s Table of contents: Why Jenkins Why Merlin for Jenkins What is Merlin for Jenkins How Merlin for Jenkins works How Jenkins on k8s work Some anticipated FAQs Why Jenkins Jenkins remains a popular choice when it comes to CICD solution with a massive community of users and contributors (despite the fact there are new cool kids in block like Tekton etc). The way I see it (because of our love and hate relationship with it) "Jenkins is not CICD tool that you want it's the CICD t...